Ideological Games: September 12th

Gonzalo Frasca?s Newsgaming outfit has posted the September 12th game.

It is quite interesting but I think it has the problem that I wrote about earlier, that its ideology has a cartoonish clearness (the war on terror is evil, end of story). I like to see doubt in things like this. As has been discussed on Game Girl Advance, the “terrorists” in the game are really, really nice.

Couldn’t one make a game that mirrors the weird ambiguities of the real world: being critical of the war on terror while recognizing that fundamentalist political Islam is fascism by another name?

[Note added later: I begin to wonder whether some people would consider the last statement to be controversial? Is it?]

The Open and the Closed: Games of Emergence and Games of Progression

Uploaded my paper from the Computer Games and Digital Cultures conference in Finland, June 2002: The Open and the Closed: Games of Emergence and Games of Progression.

It describes a pretty basic distinction between “progression” games where the player faces a series of challenges with predefined solutions (adventure games, mostly) and “emergence” games where the rules of the game interact to create variation. The description of emergence is much more elaborate in the dissertation, by the way.

What does it take to know a Game?

We discuss it all the time at the ITU: How much time do you have to spend on a game before you can claim to be knowledgeable about it?

Gamespot have pulled their review of Savage: The Battle for Newerth in response to allegations that, according to the server stats, the reviewer had only played it for a few hours.

Here’s the original review.

It ain’t easy: Scott Osborne is generally a very good reviewer IMO and I’ve quoted him several times in papers. Perhaps he just immediately hated the game and felt that nothing more would come from playing it further. And then he may have been wrong.

Narrative is overrated. I have proof.

The story so far: It should be no surprise that a new field of academic research will reflect the theoretical sensibilities and preoccupations of the time. The emergence of video game research was just like that.
In the late 1990’s, the concept of narrative was being used by everybody, all the time, to describe everything, and so early video game researches happily employed the term on video games as well. OK, so we discussed that already. But even so:

The US department store Nordstrom has for a while had a narrative department in women’s clothing.
Here’s a picture I took at the Chicago branch:
Nordstrom Chicago women's clothing: narrative section
Which, I think, proves the point.

Terra Nova: New blog on Virtual Worlds

Dan Hunter, Greg Lastowka, Julian Dibbell and Edward Castronova anounce their new shared blog on virtual worlds, Terra Nova.

The purpose of the blog is to report and comment on critical developments in the area of emergent collective reality spaces, aka virtual worlds. Our focus is not on the worlds themselves but on the economic and legal implications of the behavior they generate.

The blog already has some interesting posts, but “emergent collective reality spaces”? What does emergent mean in this context?

Ph.D. Crunch Time

Entering the last three weeks of my Ph.D..
21 days of work if I want to meet the official deadline of October 1st.
I’ll be exhausted by the end of it, but it’s also one of those times where everything is connected. The smallest break immediately brings 10 ideas that I rush to write down. It’s also a kill your darlings-moment: I see all the brilliant flashes of insight that I can’t put in my Ph.D.; it’s unlikely I will have the time to explain why Auerbach’s Figura enlightens us on the interpretation of Super Mario Sunshine. The small amount of procrastination that I do get done is conveniently spent playing relevant games. Real procrastination is then to play irrelevant games, though my mind picks up strange connections anyway.
I am past Tim Henman and Jim Courier in Virtua Tennis on my NTSC Dreamcast, 4th seeded in the world, but beating King is really, really hard. This was meant to be a pure waste of time, but I’ve already written about how Virtua Tennis is a stylized simulation of real tennis in that many aspects of the real sport has been removed: You can’t leave the court; the player automatically positions himself for a smash. And is it cheating to quit a game in career mode if it’s not going well or should you play it to the end?